enJOY it

an archived personal and craft blog from Elise Blaha Cripe.

Advertisement Garliccreamsaucepizza

I have one more recipe to share as part of my blog collaboration with Got Milk.

This is our absolute favorite homemade pizza sauce but one that I have never shared in detail because in Paul's words, "it can be hard to get right." But hopefully with more than a few photos and a bit too much text, I'll be able to communicate the texture you're going for.

As mentioned last week, milk is a staple in our house for all three of us. Milk is, of course, also the staple of this cream sauce. 😉

Creamsauce1

To make enough to cover a normal sized pizza (here's our dough recipe!) you'll need :

  • about 1/3 of a medium onion
  • 2-3 cloves of garlic
  • about 2 Tbsp olive oil
  • 1 cup milk (we used whole milk this time, but we've made it with skim too)
  • 1/2 tsp dried basil
  • 1/2 tsp dried oregano
  • 1/2 salt (plus probably a bit more)
  • pepper to taste (a few cranks to start and then probably a bit more)
  • 1 Tbsp flour

Creamsauce2

Finely chop the garlic and onion. Then cook with the olive oil in a sauce pan over medium heat.

Creamsauce3

Just before the garlic and onion start to brown (and are looking pretty transulent), pour in just 3/4 C of the milk, saving the remaining 1/4 for later.

Creamsauce4

Turn heat to medium low and add your seasonings.

Creamsauce5

Let this mixture bubble (keeping the heat at medium low).

Creamsauce6

In the measuring cup, mix the remaining 1/4 C milk and flour well (ideally, you'll have no chunks of flour!)

Creamsauce7

Crank the heat up to medium and add the flour and milk mixture to the saucepan.

Creamsauce8

Here's where it gets a bit tricky. You want to continually stir the sauce to keep flour from getting lumpy. The goal here is to create a uniformly thick sauce.

Creamsauce9

It takes about 10-15 minutes and you can gradually lower the heat as the sauce thickens up. When you stop stirring for a bit you should see small bubbles rising to the surface. This is good!

Creamsauce10

You'll know when the sauce is ready because you'll be able to drag your spoon through and make a path to the bottom of the pan. (The fact that the sauce holds it's shape means it's thick enough.)

Creamsauce11

When you turn the heat down it will thicken up even more (and be perfect for spreading on a pizza). Be sure to taste it at this step! Does it need more salt and/or pepper?

Creamsaucepizza

Our favorite cream sauce topping is (cooked) steak and thinly sliced potato (with a bit of blue cheese!) but this is a killer sauce for a veggie pizza too (think thinly sliced bell pepper and small pieces of broccoli).

Gotmilk

Hope you enjoy!

this post is sponsored by Got Milk. Recipe is Paul's concoction and opinions & post concept are my own.

Posted in

19 responses to “the best garlic cream pizza sauce.”

  1. Nolwenn Avatar

    nice ! I love white pizze.
    Do you know, by chance, if this would work with non dairy milk as well ? I know the consistency is different and can make it fail but asking in case you experimented with making it dairy free 🙂

    Like

  2. PrairieCoast Avatar
    PrairieCoast

    We do a very similar sauce. The method I use for cream sauces is to add the flour to the oil/onion/garlic mixture, stirring constantly until bubbly and slightly browned. Then I would add all the milk slowly while stirring/whisking constantly. I personally find this way a bit easier to avoid lumps. Just an alternative method to get to same end result. If you keep the sauce a bit thinner and add Parmesan cheese, you’ve got a delicious Alfredo sauce for pasta. On a pizza, we like to top it with steak and sauteed mushrooms, peppers, and onions. Love the potato idea, will definitely try! Great recipe!

    Like

  3. elise blaha cripe Avatar

    good question! I have not tried with anything but cow’s milk. Could be worth a try! 🙂

    Like

  4. elise blaha cripe Avatar

    yum! thanks for sharing!

    Like

  5. Megan Dunn Avatar
    Megan Dunn

    When I click on your archives page, and then the link that is supposed to take me to the ‘archives by date’ page, it just takes me to the ‘archive by topic’ page. Do you know how I can get to the ‘by date’ page?

    Like

  6. Erica Avatar
    Erica

    Hi Elise! I love the recipe but would like to know how much salt. Maybe I’m missing it, but I don’t see where it says tsp or tbl? We are serious garlic lovers at my house so I would love to give this recipe a go. Thank you. ☺️

    Like

  7. Carolyn Williams Avatar

    This looks so great! We try to have pizza every Friday because it’s the only food that is motivating enough to not just decide to eat out. I’ve been trying to mix it up a little, and this looks perfect. I love potatoes on pizza… Have you tried sausage and potato? It’s amazing. We had it with an almost breakfast tasting sausage at a brewery and it was life changing.

    Like

  8. Anne Avatar

    I’ve done sauces like this with almond milk too and it totally works! (non-sweetened of course)

    Like

  9. Anne Avatar

    Yum yum! I love the idea of adding broccoli as a topping for this! mmm!

    Like

  10. Lauren Avatar

    Thanks for sharing! I love that the ingredients are easy things we already have! I cant wait to try. Up to this point my go to pizza sauces are either ranch or melted butter or olive oil+garlic, so I cant want to step it up a notch!

    Like

  11. Welcome Home Taylor Avatar

    wow! This looks delicious!
    xoxo
    Taylor

    Like

  12. Britta Cait Avatar

    This looks absolutely delicious!

    Like

  13. J3SS1C4 Avatar

    Yum, this sounds amazing! I’ve never tried steak on the pizzas I make, so thanks for the idea! 🙂

    Like

  14. birdywordy Avatar
    birdywordy

    Hi Elise,
    I actually made this last night (the 12th)! I tried it sprinkled over pesto with prosciutto, mushrooms, and mozzarella on top. It was really good. Thanks for posting. 🙂

    Like

  15. Catherine Daly Avatar
    Catherine Daly

    We made over the weekend – so scrumptious thanks for sharing. We have long been converts of homemade pizzas thanks to your wholewheat dough recipe…as have my parents! x

    Like

  16. Natalie Nunn Avatar

    Wow! I just made this for dinner tonight and it was so so good! My husband and I have been making way more pizzas thanks to you 🙂

    Like

  17. Sherilyn Avatar
    Sherilyn

    Just made the sauce tonight with soy milk and it turned out great!

    Like

  18. cricketgirl Avatar
    cricketgirl

    This sounds amazingly delicious! We’ve been ordering pizza w/garlic white sauce from a chain thats really good but I ALWAYS prefer homemade so I decided to go in search of recipes. I think I’ve foind one that will be PERFECT. This will definately be tommorows supper. However we’re met lovers so it’ll have some salami, bacon, pepperoni and beef along with mushrooms, black olives, bell pepper and onions on a thin, crunchy crust. 🙂

    Like

  19. Rick Avatar
    Rick

    We did it with some chicken breast tenderloins we had soaking in lemon juice and black pepper, turned out really well!

    Like

Leave a comment